3.20.2024

This is a tasting.

Bonus Taste

Submitted by CA

Initial Impressions

  • BE – 84 proof | 1 year | Score: 5
    “Tequila”
  • PD – 80 proof | 6 mos | Score: 6.5
  • DA – 80 proof | 6 mos | Score 3
    “would not try again”
  • JD – 80 proof | 2 years | Score: 7
    “Tequila”
  • CA – Score: 7

The Reveal

Casa Del Sol Angel’s Reserve Tequila

80 Proof | Blend of Anejo and Extra Anejo | $200 MSRP

An elegant blend of Añejo and Extra Añejo aged in French Oak and XO Cognac barrels. Notes of honey, toffee, butterscotch, and dried fruit marry to create this soft, balanced tequila

Average Score: 5.7


Taste 1

Submitted by CA

Initial Impressions

  • DA – 90 proof | 6 years | Score: 7
    “Maybe a rye”
  • JD – 96 proof | 6 years | Score: 7
    “finished in something interesting”
  • PD – 95 proof | 7 years | Score: 7
    “warm spices, bourbon”
  • BE – 94 proof | 6 years | Score: 6
  • CA – Score: 6

The Reveal

1792 Bottled in Bond

100 Proof | NAS | $45 MSRP

This well-aged bourbon comes from only barrels filled during the same distilling season and is bottled at exactly 100 proof for a bold taste and lingering finish—a testament to the Bottled-in-Bond Act established over a century ago.

The unmistakable spice of 1792 Bourbon is met with notes of charred oak and fresh mint. Subtle caramel apple tones are delicately balanced with the lingering essence of coffee and black pepper.

Average Score: 6.6


Taste 2

Submitted by DA

Initial Impressions

  • PD – 103 proof | 5 years | Score: 6
    “finished in a wine barrel”
  • JD – 110 proof | 6 years | Score: 3
    “finished in something”
  • BE – 100 proof | 8 years | Score 4
  • CA – 108 proof | 6 years | Score: 6.75
    “tingly tannins”
  • DA – Score: 6.75

The Reveal

Bondstone Triple Oak Batch 1

100 Proof | NAS | $70 MSRP

Average Score: 5.3


Taste 3

Submitted by PD

Initial Impressions

  • BE – 100 proof | 4 years | Score: 5
  • JD – 95 proof | 3 years | Score: 5.5
  • CA – 100 proof | 4 years | Score: 5
    “finished in maple syrup”
  • DA – 96 proof | 4 years | Score: 6.25
  • PD – 7

The Reveal

Kinsey 8 Year

108 Proof | 8 years old | $65 MSRP

Average Score: 5.75


Taste 4

Submitted by BE

Initial Impression

  • PD – 93 proof | 6 years | Score: 7.5
  • DA – 98 proof | 8 years | Score: 7.5
    “finished in something?”
  • JD – 100 proof | 6 years | Score 6.5
  • CA – 100 proof | 6 years | Score: 7.75
  • BE – 7.5

The Reveal

1792 Single Barrel

98.6 Proof | NAS | $45 MSRP

Average Score: 7.35


Taste 5

Submitted by JD

Initial Impressions

  • BE – 102 proof | 5 years | Score: 6
  • PD – 100 proof | 8 years | Score: 6
  • CA – 100 proof | 6 years | Score: 6.5
  • DA – 100 proof | 8 years | Score: 6.5
  • JD – Score: 6.5

The Reveal

High West Cask Collection Chardonnay

100 Proof | NAS | $? MSRP

Average Score: 6.3